***Contains Spoilers***
Alan Moore and Brian Bolland’s Batman: The Killing Joke is a legendary graphic novel that has become an essential part of Batman’s mythos. At its core, it is a chilling story that explores the Joker’s twisted psyche and his belief that “one bad day” can break even the strongest soul. The plot intertwines a horrifying attack on Barbara Gordon with the Joker’s attempts to push Commissioner Gordon to the brink of madness, all while presenting a potential origin story for the Clown Prince of Crime. Batman’s pursuit of the Joker and their philosophical clash form the backbone of this unforgettable tale.
What struck me most about this story was its boldness. The Joker’s attack on Barbara—shooting her point-blank and leaving her paralyzed—was shocking and remains a pivotal moment in DC Comics history. It’s not just physical violence; the psychological torment the Joker inflicts, particularly on Commissioner Gordon, is equally unsettling. The circus sequence, where Gordon is stripped naked and forced to endure images of his injured daughter, was profoundly disturbing. It’s a scene that highlights the Joker’s depravity while reinforcing Gordon’s resilience. Brian Bolland’s artwork amplifies the horror, with each panel brimming with detail and emotion. The use of lighting and shadow, especially in the Joker’s flashbacks, creates an eerie atmosphere that lingers long after the story ends.
Beyond the shocking moments, I appreciated the philosophical underpinnings of the story. The Joker’s belief that chaos and madness lie just beneath the surface of every individual is terrifyingly compelling. Meanwhile, Batman’s unwavering commitment to justice and his refusal to abandon Gordon in his darkest hour serve as a counterpoint to the Joker’s nihilism. Their final confrontation is quiet but laden with tension, and the ambiguous ending still sparks debates decades later.
However, there are aspects of The Killing Joke that left me uneasy. Barbara’s treatment in the story feels exploitative. Her injury and trauma are used primarily to advance the Joker’s plan and drive Batman and Gordon’s narratives. While her paralysis led to her reinvention as Oracle—one of DC’s most inspiring heroes—this story doesn’t give her much agency, which feels like a missed opportunity. Additionally, the story’s grim tone may be off-putting for some readers. While I admire its intensity, it’s not a book I would recommend lightly, as its graphic content can be overwhelming.
In conclusion, Batman: The Killing Joke is a masterfully crafted story that cements its place as an all-time classic in the Batman canon. Alan Moore’s writing is thought-provoking, and Brian Bolland’s art is stunning in its precision and moodiness. It is a difficult, challenging read, but one that offers deep insights into the characters of Batman and the Joker. That said, the problematic treatment of Barbara Gordon and the heavy tone prevent me from giving it a perfect score. I highly recommend it to fans of Batman and those who appreciate complex, mature storytelling. 4 stars
Feature Image The Killing Joke art by Brian Bolland and Richard Starkings
Keep NewToComics.com running with a donation or shopping with through our affiliates—your support helps maintain the site and continue guiding new readers into the world of comics!