***Contains Spoilers***
Batman Chronicles #5: “Oracle: Year One” offers a deep dive into Barbara Gordon’s transformation into Oracle. Taking place after the tragic events of The Killing Joke, it explores her initial struggles with her new reality, her resilience, and the moment she begins building the identity of the all-seeing information broker we’ve come to know. The narrative features Barbara confronting a forgettable hacker antagonist while finding her inner strength to move forward.
What really stood out for me was how well this issue delves into Barbara’s psychology. Her journey feels authentic as she works through feelings of despair, frustration, and, ultimately, empowerment. The decision to become Oracle is neither rushed nor overly dramatic—it’s a realistic and meaningful step forward. The writing does a great job of capturing her inner monologue and her quiet strength as she chooses to channel her brilliance in a new direction.
However, while Barbara’s story is compelling, the villain leaves much to be desired. The hacker antagonist serves only as a plot device, and their lack of any real presence or personality makes them completely forgettable. This detracts from the story’s tension and makes the central conflict feel a little flat. Given the importance of this moment in Barbara’s life, a stronger antagonist could have elevated the stakes.
At just one issue, “Oracle: Year One” is a quick read, but it’s worth picking up for fans of Barbara Gordon or anyone interested in her origin as Oracle. While it’s not groundbreaking, it’s an introspective and impactful story that does justice to its protagonist.
3 Stars – I liked it and plan to reread it, though it’s not essential reading. It’s a solid, if slightly flawed, exploration of a pivotal moment in Barbara Gordon’s life.
Feature Image The Batman Chronicles #5 cover art by Howard Chaykin and Tommy Lee Edwards