Review of Batman: Batgirl #1 Girlfrendzy!

What I appreciated most was the focus on Batgirl’s raw determination and cleverness. This isn’t a story where she leans on Batman’s guidance or tech; instead, it highlights her ability to navigate peril on her own terms. Puckett captures the vulnerability of a rookie hero while still showcasing her potential, which is compelling to see. The idea of pitting Batgirl against Zsasz—one of Gotham’s most deranged killers—is bold and sets up a unique dynamic. Zsasz’s chilling presence as a villain does give the story some weight, even if his role feels somewhat underutilized.

That said, the execution left a lot to be desired. The pacing felt rushed, with little room to build tension or explore Batgirl’s growth meaningfully. The story’s simplicity quickly became a detriment, as the confrontation with Zsasz lacked the depth or emotional payoff I was hoping for. The artwork was serviceable but not particularly memorable, and at times the action sequences felt cluttered. For a one-shot meant to spotlight Batgirl, I wanted more exploration of her character beyond just her skills and determination. The dialogue also occasionally leaned into clichés, making the interactions feel less impactful.